Red Cross, UNHCR —And Prison Director— Agree: Stop Arresting Irregular Migrants

Red Cross, UNHCR —And Prison Director— Agree: Stop Arresting Irregular Migrants

At least one man from Ghana, arrested for false ID, was enslaved in prison, says lawyer

Published December 22, 2014

“I don’t understand how a society can afford to break people this way,” said the UNHCR’s Pia Prytz Phiri at the Red Cross’ press meeting last Tuesday, referring to the conditions asylum seekers in Iceland have endured in recent years. Lawyer Katrín Oddsdóttir has described the situation of at least one imprisoned asylum seeker as slavery.

Phiri says the UNHCR will continue to press Iceland to cease arresting and imprisoning those who, seeking asylum, enter the country on false IDs. This was reported by DV.

On Sunday, RÚV reported that Páll Winkel, Director of the Icelandic Prison Service, called the systematic arrests of asylum seekers “completely futile”.

The UNHCR and the Red Cross

As reported, Phiri, the Baltic and Nordic Regional Representative for the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), already reprimanded Iceland in November 2013, on behalf of the UNHCR, not least for the habit of systematically arresting migrants who travel with false passports. “I want to make it very clear that [the UNHCR] considers this unjustifiable,” she said at that occasion. “It is plainly stated that you cannot punish refugees for illegally entering a country.”

Article 31 of the UN Refugee Convention states clearly that: “States shall not impose penalties, on account of their illegal entry or presence, on refugees who, coming directly from a territory where their life or freedom was threatened … enter or are present in their territory without authorization, provided they present themselves without delay to the authorities and show good cuase for their illegal entry or presence.”

Last Tuesday, Phiri verified that some improvements had been made, regarding Iceland’s treatment of refugees, but reiterated her critique of the systematic arrests: “It is true that we have seen certain changes in legislation, but not in regard with automatic arrests of people who travel with false ID. We are concerned about this”, she said, adding that the UNHCR “will keep trying to convince Iceland not to use custody except as last resort.”

This weekend, the Red Cross urged Icelandic authorities to follow the example set by Norway, where, last Friday, a law became valid which forbids the imprisonment of refugees traveling on false passports.

Prison Director Calls Arrests Of Refugees “Completely Futile”

On Sunday, Páll Winkel, Director of the Icelandic Prison Service, echoed the UNHCR’s and the Red Cross’ concerns. He said that imprisonment for traveling with false IDs has no deterrence effect, and thereby serves no purpose at all. This was reported by RÚV.

“First and foremost I find it said, as we who work in the system know that often these people are victims of human trafficking, and have been through serious hardships. These are people, for example, from Afghanistan and Syria,” Páll said.

“Each year, between 25 and 50 people come here for fifteen days and are then thrown out. This serves absolutely no purpose. We cannot take care of these people. Most often they are unable to speak so we cannot provide them with any assistance,” Páll said, and expressed his doubts as to whether “people in Afghanistan know if people are imprisoned for fifteen days in Iceland if they travel on false passports. That is completely futile and the reasoning of those who want to preserve this system, let alone toughen it — well, I’d like to see it.”

450 people currently await serving a prison sentence, Páll said, while arrested asylum seekers are given priority in the system. He said that hardened criminals are rare among asylum seekers. Páll added that often those arrested do neither realise where they are nor in which circumstances.

Ögmundur Jónasson, member of Alþingi and former Minister of the Interior on behalf of the Left-Green Party, has proposed a resolution, by which Alþingi would forbid such arrests.

Refugees enslaved in prison

RÚV also reports that Lawyer Katrín Oddsdóttir has described the situation of at least one imprisoned asylum seeker as slavery: “One of my clients was used as a sort of slave, forced to do the dishes for the others, and then he was beaten. In the end he had to be transferred to another jail, because he was so threatened by other prisoners. This was a man who barely spoke any English, let alone Iceland. He got no assistance. This is dead serious. And here, the State is, in my opinion, violating against people’s human rights. They are held captive and it is the State’s duty to ensure that they do not suffer degrading treatment, not to mention violent”.

Already in November 2013, DV covered the story of a man from Ghana, arrested on his arrival, for carrying a false passport, then enslaved and degraded by local prisoners.



News
Decision To Deny Muslim School Teacher Flight To US Made By American Authorities

Decision To Deny Muslim School Teacher Flight To US Made By American Authorities

by

The Grapevine has confirmed that a British school teacher who was denied entry onto a flight from Keflavík Airport to

News
Fears “Vape Law” Could Create Black Market For Vaping Oil

Fears “Vape Law” Could Create Black Market For Vaping Oil

by

A proposal that would put a number of regulations on the sale and use of e-cigarettes is poorly thought-out, and

News
Fisherman’s Strike Ends: “We Had A Gun To Our Heads”, Says Union Leader

Fisherman’s Strike Ends: “We Had A Gun To Our Heads”, Says Union Leader

by

The strike that went on for about two months has finally drawn to a close, but one union official says

News
Beached Whale(?) Washes Up In Snæfellsnes

Beached Whale(?) Washes Up In Snæfellsnes

by

A creature that appears to be a whale was spotted on the southern coast of Snæfellsnes last Saturday. Rúna Björg

News
“Keeping Up With The Kattarshians” A Great Success

“Keeping Up With The Kattarshians” A Great Success

by

Thousands of Icelanders are watching a livestream of four siblings – who happen to be kittens – living together in

News
Despite Losses, Minke Whale Quota To Increase This Year

Despite Losses, Minke Whale Quota To Increase This Year

by

Tourism is reportedly driving up the demand for minke whale meat to such an extent that this year’s quota will

Show Me More!