From Iceland — Best Of Reykjavík Dining 2021: Best Traditional Icelandic Food

Best Of Reykjavík Dining 2021: Best Traditional Icelandic Food

Best Of Reykjavík Dining 2021: Best Traditional Icelandic Food

Published September 16, 2021

Photo by
Art Bicnick

While the pandemic shows no sign of abating, Iceland’s food and beverage industry seems to be surging ahead on a combination of hope, optimism and high spirits despite the many challenges posed by COVID. In a year full of uncertainties, restaurants old and new showed us what resilience looks like. Take-away took on a whole new meaning with at-home meal kits being offered up by celebrated chefs, marked-down menus becoming commonplace and spirited underground deliveries brightened many evenings.

Our expert panel of gourmands were hand-picked for their dedication to food—these people eat out way more than one should and can sift the mojo from the mayo with ease. While it has been a difficult year, the winners rose to the challenge, and how! Adversity does bring out the best in some and this year we are delighted to shine light on our out-of-town superstars who often eclipse their Reykjavík counterparts by miles. So sit tight, and let us help you navigate these gastronomic waters, be it the hottest burger in town or the most memorable dining experience of your life.

Best Traditional Icelandic Food

Café Loki

Lokastígur 28

Photo by art Bicnick

Long before Icelandic food was considered cool, this unassuming cafe was unabashedly celebrating tradition. From the classic farm-style kjötsúpa (lamb soup, although we recommend trying the rye bread soup as well—it’s part what the heck, part dessert, but all delicious) to herring and plökkfiskur, everything is a throwback to how the island once ate. The carrot-cake doppelganger Freyja is a trout brauðterta (savoury sandwich cake) that is retro yet tasty. And for those writing their own tales of bravado, there is fermented shark to be washed down with Brennivín—a convenient platter for bragging rights.

Runner-Up:

Kaffivagninn

Grandagarður 10

Photo by Kaffivagninn

Iceland’s oldest running restaurant, Kaffivagninn’s enviable location by the harbour is best enjoyed on a sunny day, out on the deck, a cold brew in one hand and a mighty slice of brauðterta in the other. Portions are very much sailor sized, and the plokkfiskur is a throwback to amma’s place, with one portion enough to feed two full-grown adults. Other Icelandic classics like fiskibollur and schnitzel are also on offer. The place continues to draw patrons from morning coffees to the popular evening shift, only made better by a slice of their homemade cake.

Runner-Up:

Þrír Frakkar

Baldursgata 14

Photo by Þrír Frakkar

Þrir Frakkar had its strong sense of Icelandic food culture on display long before it was fashionable.. This restaurant has not let anything sway them from tradition—you’ll spot everything on the menu, from foal and blackbird, to cod throats and plokkfiskur, which will all remain long in your memory. A visit to this place underlines the fact that good old-fashioned Icelandic cooking can be all kinds of memorable.


You can buy a copy of the full Best Of Reykjavík 2021 magazine—an essential guide to having fun in Reykjavík—here, posted worldwide. 

Support The Reykjavík Grapevine!
Buy subscriptions, t-shirts and more from our shop right here!

Best-of-reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best Homeware Shop

Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best Homeware Shop

by

Best-of-reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best Bookstore

Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best Bookstore

by

Best-of-reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best  Record Store

Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best Record Store

by

Best-of-reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best Goddamn Store

Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best Goddamn Store

by

Best-of-reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best Clothing Store

Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best Clothing Store

by

Best-of-reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík
Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best Fashion Boutique

Best Of Reykjavík Shopping 2021: Best Fashion Boutique

by

Show Me More!