Mag
Articles
Where is the Icelandic Aristotle?

Where is the Icelandic Aristotle?

Published July 20, 2009

Iceland only seems to be large enough to accommodate one, or at best two, points of view at a time. While our Scandinavian cousins were busy inventing model societies that stood somewhere between the two extremes of American Capitalism and Soviet Communism, and achieved a wide consensus among their populations in doing so, Iceland was deeply divided between left and right. Mid-century newspapers seem almost comical to us now in their fervent Cold War rhetoric, but how much has really changed?
A wound that will never heal
In the Post-war era, you were either opposed to or in agreement with the US military presence, and the debate took the form of sloganeering when at its best and teargas at its worst. This rift has never quite healed. In the past decade, no neutral ground seems to have been found between conservationists who are often portrayed as being in principle against modernity, and industrialists who seem to want to dam every river, waterfall or hot spring they can find. In political discourse, you seem to have to be either for or against nature, which is quite a remarkable feat of oppositional thinking.
When faced with the issue of joining the European Union, this problem becomes apparent yet again. On the one hand you have people who are portrayed, Cold War style, as traitors who want to sell Iceland’s independence to foreigners. On the other hand, you have people who are portrayed as wanting to sever all connections with the outside world. About the actual pros and cons of joining the EU, we hear very little.
Tap water journalism
As usual, the media is at least partially to blame. Icelandic news programmes and papers are run on a shoestring budget by all international standards. Investigative journalism is both expensive and time consuming. The cheapest option is what has quite appropriately been called “tap water journalism.” You get two people with opposing views, and then you turn them on and off like hot and cold water. With no one in a position to present the actual facts, political debate is quickly reduced to the level of a football game with no referee where everyone simply cheers their side reduction ad absurdum.
Aristotle said that for every virtue there are two vices, both located at opposite ends of the spectrum. He would no doubt say that those who see the EU as the devil incarnate as well as those who see it as the answer to all our prayers are equally wrong.  The answer, no doubt, lies somewhere in the middle. Only by examining things from there can we truly see what is the right path. Tap water actually works best when hot and cold are mixed together. How much of each should be the subject of political debate, not either or. Even when, as with the EU, one must eventually decide one way or another. 



Mag
Articles
Iceland Strikes Again!

Iceland Strikes Again!

by

The conventional wisdom says that Iceland is a happy, prosperous place with that strong Nordic welfare system. But if things

Mag
Articles
So What’re These Lambs On TV I Keep Hearing About?

So What’re These Lambs On TV I Keep Hearing About?

by

Starting at noon on May 14, Icelandic state television RÚV broadcast continuously for almost 24 hours from a farm called

Mag
Articles
Fine dining in Iceland in 1809: “A Most Involuntary Intemperance”

Fine dining in Iceland in 1809: “A Most Involuntary Intemperance”

by

In the summer of 1809, a young British botanist, William Hooker, visited Iceland on the first botanical expedition of what

Mag
Articles
Holuhraun Has Stopped Erupting, But Is It Still Dangerous?

Holuhraun Has Stopped Erupting, But Is It Still Dangerous?

by

The Holuhraun eruption finally ended on February 27 of this year after six months, leaving behind a lava field that

Mag
Articles
Channing Tatum Is In Iceland: We Stalked Him Online

Channing Tatum Is In Iceland: We Stalked Him Online

by

Former stripper and Hollywood actor Channing Tatum has arrived in Iceland and emotions are running high. Naturally, Icelanders have dropped

Mag
Articles
News In Brief: May

News In Brief: May

by

As per hallowed Icelandic media tradition, Grapevine joined in the fun of kicking off the month of April with fake

Show Me More!