Culture
Sugar Paper Theories: Notorious Murder Case Through The Lens

Sugar Paper Theories: Notorious Murder Case Through The Lens

Jenna Mohammed
Words by
Photos by
Art Bicnick

Published October 6, 2017

Iceland’s biggest and most controversial murder investigation is brought back to life in the exhibit Sugar Paper Theories. British photographer, Jack Latham uses the Guðmundur and Geirfinnur case as a platform to explore the different ways we interpret images.

The famous case, which centers around a disappearance, has recently been taken back to court and is also the subject of the new documentary ‘Out Of thin Air.’ The incident occurred in the mid ‘70s, when Guðmundur Einarsson went missing in Hafnarfjörður. Ten months later, Geirfinnur Einarsson—who is not related to Guðmundur—never returned to his car which he had parked in Keflavík. In the following investigations, six people confessed to crimes they could not recall, making the case truly iconic.

Land of stories

 Sugar Paper Theories looks at photographs as contextual evidence and plays with how they reveal our perception of memory, truth and ambiguity. Jack Latham gravitated to this case for various reasons. He claims, “In particular, Iceland has a connection with the idea of storytelling. There’s a long history of storytelling within Iceland, and the setting is a really interesting place.” He continues “I believe it’s one of the largest injustices in Europe. Really when you break down what happened in this case, it’s a form of storytelling.”

“I believe it’s one of the largest injustices in Europe. Really when you break down what happened in this case, it’s a form of storytelling.”

Photography is just another way of portraying an event, but the question of what is tangible remains. “I was initially interested in this case because I believe it’s linked well with photography,” says Jack. “It’s the idea of misdirection and misinformation. We live in a time where fake news is now vernacular. As a photographer I create bodies of work and I take photos seemingly out of context and I put them in a different context to generate a narrative.” Sugar Paper Theories delves into this theme; the recreated photographs used for the trial are comparable to a conjured story, unable to define what really occurred. Jack explains, “As much as it’s an investigation into the case, it’s also simultaneously an investigation into the medium of photography, storytelling, and how we view images.”

Fact versus fiction

 Sugar Paper Theories keeps in mind the question of what happens when photographic evidence is used to convict people. Jack believes images represent truth while they simultaneously present fiction. “There is an idea of framing and photographer bias—they decide what’s going to be in that frame,” he says. “There is inherent staging to every photograph and they aren’t always what they seem. In the case with reenactment photos, there is the element of staging where people stand in certain places or reenact certain bits. What does that mean about the term ‘evidence’ or ‘document’?”

Social media platforms such as Facebook and Instagram have elements of distress within them, Jack explains. He compares it to a parody of family photos. “You will only put positive pictures of yourself or what you deem worthy to be online. This references a family album. When you go through it there are never the bits of people crying or of funerals,” he says. “You curate a narrative of yourself and I think photography does this so well and I don’t think many people realize the implication of that. That’s what always interested me—how we curate stories about our lives and ourselves.”

Sugar Paper Theories can be viewed at the Reykjavík Museum of Photography until 14 January 2018. Free Admission.


Culture
Word Of The Issue: Olnbogabarn

Word Of The Issue: Olnbogabarn

by

Anyone who has more than one child and says they love them all equally is lying, as anyone with siblings

Culture
Great Moments In Icelandic Cuisine: Bjúga

Great Moments In Icelandic Cuisine: Bjúga

by

Tired of overpriced tattered hot dogs? Well, why not try out some long, thick bjúga? While Europe was getting all

Culture
Perfect Day: Saga Ýr Nazari

Perfect Day: Saga Ýr Nazari

by

Saga Ýr Nazari burst onto the music scene just one month ago with her debut effort ‘Don’t Gotta Be Real’.

Culture
You Wish This Was Your Birthday: Gleðileg Jón 2018 Has Arrived

You Wish This Was Your Birthday: Gleðileg Jón 2018 Has Arrived

by

“It started out as a joke on a group chat on Facebook in July 2016,” says Jón Már Ásbjörnsson, the

Culture
What Have We Won?: Overwatch Us Shine!

What Have We Won?: Overwatch Us Shine!

by

There are two sentences which strike disappointment into the heart of all parents. “I really think my mixtape is gonna

Culture
Fancies: Geiri & Gugga

Fancies: Geiri & Gugga

by

Fancies is a Grapevine series where we highlight an individual with supreme style. Our latest subjects are Sigurgeir J. Aðalsteinsson

Show Me More!