Mag
Opinion
You Have It All Wrong!

You Have It All Wrong!

Published August 28, 2012

Over the last several weeks, there has been a deluge of discussion about the Icelandic Pirate Party. Most has been downright silly, much quite misinformed, and yet some strangely relevant, if slightly off-mark. So let’s clear up a few things.
Pirate Parties derive their name, originally, from Piratbyrån, the Swedish organization set up to counteract the Hollywood-funded lobby group Antipiratbyrån. The Pirate Bay also got its name from there. The respective founders of Piratbyrån, Pirate Bay, and the Pirate Parties, came from a group of people who have for the last several decades been doing what they can to stem the tide against growing government surveillance and limitations on the freedoms of individuals.
These people are called hackers—people like myself who enjoy learning the details of systems and how to stretch their capabilities—as opposed to most users of systems who prefer to learn only the minimum necessary. The word “hacker” has been appropriated by two distinct groups. One uses it derisively to refer to people who break into computers. The other uses it constructively to refer to the tendency to expend effort towards goals that don’t seem to make much sense.
One of our goals was to make Free Software—computer programs that anybody can use for any purpose—to study and learn from, share with their friends, and improve upon at will. This is distinct from proprietary software, which restricts a user’s freedom. After that, we started building the Creative Commons: creative works for free public consumption, including the world’s largest and most comprehensive encyclopedia, Wikipedia.
A LACK OF TRANSPARENCY
Increasingly large portions of human activity is made possible by stuff that hackers made. We haven’t solved the world’s big problems yet and our anti-authoritarian efforts have been stymied by a dangerous lack of government transparency and accountability.
Back when there were real pirates on the high seas, the world was undergoing a transition. The enlightenment was in full swing, along with its rallying calls for greater rights of self-determination for individuals, access to knowledge and freedom of thought. These ideals can be summarised in two requirements: democracy and enlightenment.
Now we’re a couple of centuries down the line and we’ve had an industrial revolution, two world wars, 48 world economic collapses and the beginning of an information revolution. We’ve ousted a few kings, replaced them with presidents. We have glorified parliamentary talk shops on almost every self-governing landmass in the world. We have schools, which have confused process and substance for so long that we’ve become blind to institutionalisation and high-modernism.
But even with all the world’s information at our fingertips—sans that which is hidden from us by governments, corporations and others who play power games with the general public—we still haven’t really gotten democracy or enlightenment.
Hackers like solving problems, and over the last several decades hackers have become increasingly open about their political motivations. So much so that we now have our own political arm: pirate parties.
Now, let’s not get confused here: Not all hackers are pirates, and not all pirates are hackers. But the same core mentality permeates through both groups. The overlap is substantial.
WHAT’S IN A NAME?
Nobody criticises the Progressive Party for being one of the least progressive and most repressive parties in Icelandic politics. Nobody criticises the Independence Party for fostering a culture of strong leadership without independent thought. The Liberal Party is full of social conservatives and the Left-Greens have an alarming number of fascists. And The Social Democratic Alliance? Give me a break. Political parties in Iceland have a long history of adopting the most (oxy)moronic names they can come up with.
We chose no to go with “Sjóræningjaflokkurinn” because it doesn’t sound cool. “Píratapartýið” however came up during a meeting where we had been talking about the ways in which words keep being misappropriated and re-appropriated. In Icelandic, the word for “casino” is “spilavíti”—literally “game hell.” The word for drugs is “eiturlyf”— literally “poison medicine.”
Icelandic is very direct about its meanings—the language is very actively used as a tool of political manipulation. The current favourite is to stick the word “meint” (alleged) in front of anything—a similar thing is happening in English. It’s a dampening word which eliminates certainty.
We wanted to challenge this tyranny of language. We decided to use “Pírat,” a meaningless word burdened with counterfeit meaning, conjoined with “Partý,” which means the fun kind of party but not the political type of party. The name might still change, but it’s hardly the most important thing right now.
I really enjoy that the best people can say against us is that we have a silly name (oh noes!). A foreign name (gasp!). A name that doesn’t fit acceptable political doctrine (shame!) or befit an organisation bent on gaining power (take a hint!).
CONTROVERSIAL FREE ASSOCIATION
Actually, people have found one other thing to complain about. It’s one of our members—my colleague Birgitta Jónsdóttir. I’ll admit that in many ways it would be a hell of a lot simpler if she weren’t a member of the Icelandic Pirate Party because then self-righteous pundits would have even less to bitch about, but frankly, she is a valuable asset for a party like ours.
Birgitta gets this flak because she’s a renegade MP. Public figures should be criticized. It would be nice if it were levelled at her ideas instead of her persona, but that would require a political discourse way above the current level. Some have pointed out that she’s been a founding member of four political parties now, including The Citizens’ Movement, which was taken over some weeks after the last elections, causing the MPs to split and form The Movement; and Dögun (“Dawn”), which, let’s face it, was really disappointing.
Freethinkers love to exalt the right to self-determination, which includes a right to free association. That means you can join as many clubs, collectives, parties and organisations as you want. Harrison Owen suggested that “if at any time… you find yourself in any situation where you are neither learning nor contributing, use your two feet, go someplace else.” I wish this were common practice in politics—although it might leave the Parliament building empty quite a lot of the time.
DEMOCRATISING DEMOCRACY
Many are confused by our governance model. It’s not entirely ready yet, but it’s more or less emerging as a flat structure.
Individuals are the fundamental unit of society, not hierarchies and committees. Committees explicitly give people authority instead of implicitly allowing them to garner support for ideas. A lot of the really bad things in any governance structure stem from explicit power relations.    
Every member has voting rights on every subject and can propose ideas to their liking. If people need to discuss ideas and come to conclusions, we have workgroups. Their existence is announced on our mailing list and a page created for it on our wiki—a kind of permanent political memory—for posterity. One or more individuals can decide to form a workgroup. At least one person from the workgroup shall submit a final report to the party.
This is different from a committee because anybody can found one and anybody can join one, and anybody can report from one. Workgroups neither need nor require legitimacy—their only purpose is to expand our knowledge base. If they want to make proposals, they do so as individual members.
TRYING SOMETHING NEW
A lot of fear and loathing is directed at pirate parties for our alleged interest in “copying with impunity.” That would be silly, as everybody already copies wildly; it cannot be stopped. It’s how the universe works. Human societies could not exist without copying and remixing. Impunity is not required.
We do support intellectual monopoly reform. We see copy rights as detrimental to artists, consumers and the economy, and letters patent are useless and harmful. It is possible to fix society such that everybody benefits, but we can’t do that while intellectual monopolies are being granted. It is an unwritten rule that in democratic societies we do not allow monopolistic behaviour, and yet we grant companies the right to claim rents on cultural artefacts made by starving artists for up to 70 years? What kind of madness is this? We can do better.
Pirate Parties are formed around the idea that traditional politics is a forlorn mess, and that a dash of ingenuity, a bit of playfulness, and a whole lot of hacker ethic can help us get somewhere else. Our ideas aren’t all about copy rights and other intellectual monopolies.
They’re about information politics in general: transparency, accountability, individual freedoms, liberal markets, few and well understood regulations, and resilient social infrastructure.
Our question: How can any government function be improved by adding more information?
It doesn’t take a Pirate to see that this makes sense.
Smári McCarthy is a freedom of information activist who works for IMMI. You can follow him on Twitter @smarimc
The picture above shows (l-r) Björn Þór Jóhannesson, Birgitta Jónsdóttir, Smári McCarthy and Helgi Hrafn Gunnarsson as they meet at the University of Reykjavík to figure out how to build a decentralised political party from scratch and embed it into an oversaturated society.


Mag
Opinion
Reykjavík Forces Its Music Schools Into Bankruptcy

Reykjavík Forces Its Music Schools Into Bankruptcy

by

As you may have heard, Icelandic music teachers recently ended a five-week long strike. The music teachers’ strike was caused by a wage dispute. It was resolved when Icelandic authorities promised music teachers wages equal to those enjoyed by other teachers in Iceland. Now that these demands have been met—even if only to certain degree—we music teachers ought to be able to continue our work, educating Iceland’s future crop of musicians. But, are we? Not necessarily. For instance, my school, Söngskóli Sigurðar Demetz (“The Vocal Academy of Sigurður Demetz”), can now prepare students for the upcoming Christmas concerts. However, if

Mag
Opinion
Good Ol’ Traditions

Good Ol’ Traditions

by

One of last week’s loudest debates has to do with next year’s State Treasury budget, which Alþingi has been debating, as tradition has it, these last days before Christmas. Among the proposed changes in taxation is the lowering of VAT on electric appliances, and a corresponding raised VAT on food products. The What Since the proposal was first introduced, these two particular changes, seen as complimentary, have been disputed. The opposition’s reasoning seems obvious: food is an unavoidable expense, and expensive food will hit hardest those with already meager income. Electric appliances, however, remain a largely optional expense, and higher

Mag
Opinion
Spotify: The Market Sets The Price

Spotify: The Market Sets The Price

by

Recently, the independent news site Nútíminn, leader among independent news sites named Nútíminn, ran an Op-Ed by a terribly uninformed man who apparently believes he can run a record company without, it seems, having any sort of a business degree. In his screed, he insists that Supply and Demand break up, because their age old relationship no longer suits his specific needs. Furthermore, he seems to believe that record sales and online streaming are musicians’ sole source of revenue, and that free market capitalism should no longer require businesses to either adapt or perish. Should you be reading this, Haraldur Leví

Mag
Opinion
Iceland’s Economy Shrinks In Third Quarter

Iceland’s Economy Shrinks In Third Quarter

by

After years of growing at a respectable rate, the Icelandic economy seems to have stalled. According to the most recent measurements of Statistics Iceland the Icelandic, published on December 5, the Icelandic economy barely registered any growth over the first nine months of the year, and actually shrunk in the third quarter. These results stand in stark contrast to the extremely rosy projections of a couple of weeks ago, which promised a growth rate of 2.7% over the year. Analysts at the large banks were similarly projecting growth around 3% for the year. Now it seems more likely we will

Mag
Opinion
Be A Peaceful Infant Smiling In The Manger

Be A Peaceful Infant Smiling In The Manger

by

Feast of lights and love, the family days of Christmas; “what to dine and how to dress”— oh, don’t we all just thrill up on the quirky-looking sweaters and find it all so amusing? And don’t we, just this season, take the necessity of “having a good time” all too seriously concerning all the consumerism attached, as it is almost obligatory to accept February’s Visa bill without any grudge, the late-Christmas-hangover? At least, most of the time “doin’ what ya wanna cuz it’s Xmas” has been, in my context, stepping just a little bit over the line; knowing how much

Mag
Opinion
The Nature Pass: The Stupidest Tax In History

The Nature Pass: The Stupidest Tax In History

by

According to official estimates, the number of foreign tourists in Iceland will top the one million mark for the first time in history by the end of the year. Which means it will have more than tripled over the course of last decade: in 2003, some 300,000 foreigners visited Iceland. Trampling hordes But while the growing number of foreign visitors has helped fuel economic growth, the hordes of visitors pose problems of their own. Virtually every popular tourist destination in Iceland is under serious stress, as irreparable damage is being done by trampling tourists. The problem is that neither the Icelandic

Show Me More!